What's the Difference Between Individual and Group Mentoring?

Whatever you are up to in life, support can make the difference between success and just being average.   But support is often looked at as a sign of weakness.  Based on our society, you should be able to do it yourself!  Though this is not true, it's one of many challenges on the way to success.  

Let's look at the costs and payoffs of these two mentoring modalities.

One-on-one positives

  1. Personal attention

  2. Go at your own pace

  3. Focus on your projects

  4. Schedule that works for you

  5. Speed up and slow down as needed

  6. Based solely on your needs and personality

  7. Custom sessions

  8. Custom actions to vision

  9. Accountability is high

One-on-one negatives

  1. No place to hide

  2. Focus on your actions

  3. Cost

  4. Accountability 

  5. May not be a match

  6. Value drift over time

  7. Personality clash is possible 

  8. Driving pace

Group mentoring positives

  1. Attention is spread throughout the group

  2. Learn by watching others

  3. Get support from the group

  4. Other perspectives 

  5. Medium pace

  6. Light focus

  7. Sessions can be missed and made up by listening to recordings

  8. Set agenda

  9. Medium accountability

  10. Half the cost

Group mentoring negatives

  1. Lack of personal attention

  2. Boredom

  3. Pace is set by the slowest person in the group

  4. Personality dynamics with other group members

  5. Not enough accountability to hold you to taking action

  6. Group think

  7. Getting away with not showing up

  8. Not getting what you paid for

  9. Lost in the shuffle

As you look at both modalities, think back on your time in school.  Did you enjoy team or individual sports?  Did you thrive in a group, or with personal attention?  Were you inspired by a  personal mentor?  Have you ever been mentored by a single, powerful individual?  What would be a stretch around support and this next part of your life?  What would have you stepping out of your comfort zone?  What would lead to the realization of your new vision?  

When you see the path, take the first step. 

Sit down today and make a costs and benefits sheet for yourself with each type of coaching.  Which list is longer?  Which list inspires you?  What jumps out at you as you view the two lists?  What are the obvious next actions to take?  Remember, coaching adds speed, depth and power.  If success was easy, everyone would be doing it.  When you see the path, take the first step.  And do it today.  Remember, no one gets to success without support.